Fall Pies - On Sale Now!

Apple. Cherry. Raspberry. Peach Blackberry. Pumpkin. Pecan. Blueberry.
And Introducing Pumpkin Praline & Apple Pear Cranberry.

Thanksgiving Pies (& Coffee) will be on sale through November 14, 2017 at 9:00pm and available for pick-up on in Cedar Falls on Wednesday, November 15 from 5:30-7:00pm by the main office and Sunday, November 19 after both worship services in the Atrium at Orchard Hill Church. Pies (& Coffee) will also be available for pick up in Grundy Center on Sunday, November 19 between worship services from 10:15-10:45am at our Grundy County Location (1800 G. Ave. Grundy Center). Pickup Location are chosen during checkout. Details will be sent in each pie order confirmation. All pies are sold frozen with baking instructions included.

A few pies will be available for purchase on Sunday morning during pie pickup.

Pumpkin Praline (NEW!)

Pumpkin Praline (NEW!)

A smooth pumpkin pie topped with a crunchy pecan streusel. A blend of our favorite Fall flavors.
(SOLD OUT!)
Apple Pear Cranberry (NEW!)

Apple Pear Cranberry (NEW!)

A holiday medley of three flavorful fruits to warm your heart and home this winter season.
(SOLD OUT!)
Dutch Apple Pie

Dutch Apple Pie

Warm apples, crumbly top and and a touch of cinnamon. Our biggest seller!
(SOLD OUT!)
Cherry Pie

Cherry Pie

A fresh spin on a classic. Sweet cherries in between a double crust pie. Bursting with flavor.
(SOLD OUT!)
Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin Pie

All the flavors of Fall packed into our seasonal pumpkin pie. This pie comes baked, just thaw and serve!
(SOLD OUT!)
Pecan Pie

Pecan Pie

Rich flavors of halved pecans in a buttery, flakey crust. This pie comes baked, just thaw and serve!
(SOLD OUT!)
Raspberry Pie

Raspberry Pie

Sun Ripened berries and a splash of lemon with a crumb topping.
(SOLD OUT!)
Peach Blackberry

Peach Blackberry

A colorful blend tart blackberries and flavorful peaches nestled under our brown sugar crumb topping.
(SOLD OUT!)
Blueberry Pie

Blueberry Pie

Fresh berries mixed with a hint of vanilla blanketed under our brown sugar crumb topping.
Sidecar Try Pie Blend

Sidecar Try Pie Blend

Sidecar Coffee Roasters will donate a % of sales from their signature blend directly to Try Pie.

Special Orders & Special Events

"My husbands eyes light up when I walk in the door with a Try Pie! We have tried at least 5 flavors and loved every one!"Juli Camarin

For large events, we offer individual mini pies* (3” and 4”) and large pies (9”) baked fresh to order. Contact This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. to find out more about availability, pricing and delivery options for your next special event!

*Minimum order of Mini Pies is 50 pies.

Can’t wait?

Check out these options for enjoying Try Pie all year long! 

Pie Pickup Instructions

"Those little pies are awesome. It’s funny how the little size makes them as cute as they are delicious!" - Lois Nanke

Your pies come frozen* and will be available to be picked up from Orchard Hill Church in Cedar Falls. Pie pickup will be on available the week before Thanksgiving after both morning worship services. You will be emailed the week before with your specific instructions for pickup. All pies are sold frozen with baking instructions included.

Get Notified when Pies Are On Sale!

* indicates required
 

Press enter to search
Press enter to search